As someone who’s spent over a decade guiding backcountry trips and advising outdoor enthusiasts, I’m frequently asked about firearm choices. One question consistently rises to the top: Mossberg 500 vs Remington 870. These two pump-action shotguns are iconic, American-made workhorses, and for good reason. Choosing between the Mossberg vs Remington options isn’t always easy, as both offer incredible versatility. Whether you’re considering a shotgun for home defense, bird hunting, or simply recreational shooting, understanding the nuances of each model – including the compact Mossberg Shockwave vs Remington alternatives – is crucial. This article will dive deep into a head-to-head comparison, helping you determine whether the Mossberg 500 or Remington 870 is the right fit for you.
Both the Mossberg 500 and Remington 870 have been in production for decades, earning reputations for durability and dependability. The Remington 870, introduced in 1950, is arguably the most popular shotgun ever made, with over 11 million sold ( Remington). The Mossberg 500, debuting in 1969, quickly became a strong competitor, known for its innovative features and affordability. Both are chambered in a variety of gauges, most commonly 12 gauge, but also available in 20 gauge, .410 bore, and others.
The Remington 870 is renowned for its smooth action and robust construction. Its receiver is machined from a single block of steel, contributing to its legendary strength. It’s a favorite among law enforcement, hunters, and competitive shooters alike. The 870’s design is relatively simple, making it easy to disassemble and maintain. However, this simplicity also means it lacks some of the features found on the Mossberg 500.
The Mossberg 500 stands out with its dual extractors and positive locking lugs. These features contribute to its reliable operation and ability to handle a wider range of ammunition. The Mossberg also incorporates a safety located on the trigger guard, which many users find more intuitive than the 870’s crossbolt safety. Furthermore, the Mossberg 500 generally offers more customization options right out of the box.
Let's break down the specifics, comparing the Mossberg 500 or Remington 870 across several critical categories.
| Feature | Remington 870 | Mossberg 500 |
|---|---|---|
| Receiver Material | Machined Steel | Aluminum Alloy |
| Safety Location | Crossbolt | Trigger Guard |
| Extractors | Single | Dual |
| Locking Lugs | Single | Dual |
| Price (Base Model) | $350 - $500 | $300 - $450 |
| Weight (12 Gauge) | 7.5 - 8 lbs | 7 - 7.75 lbs |
The Remington 870 is often praised for its exceptionally smooth action, particularly after break-in. However, the Mossberg 500’s dual extractors and positive locking lugs contribute to its consistent reliability, even with lower-powered ammunition. Some users report that the 870 can occasionally short-stroke (fail to fully cycle) with lighter loads, a problem less common with the Mossberg. Both shotguns require regular cleaning and lubrication to maintain optimal performance ( NRA).
The primary difference in safety mechanisms is the location. The Remington 870 features a crossbolt safety located behind the trigger. This requires the shooter to move their finger off the trigger to disengage the safety. The Mossberg 500’s safety is located on the trigger guard, allowing for quicker and more intuitive operation for some shooters. Ultimately, the best safety location is a matter of personal preference and training.
While both shotguns offer a wide range of aftermarket accessories, the Mossberg 500 generally has a slight edge in this area. The Mossberg’s receiver design makes it easier to install optics and other accessories. Numerous companies offer custom stocks, forends, and other parts for both models, allowing you to tailor the shotgun to your specific needs. Consider your intended use when choosing accessories – a hunter might prioritize a sling and ghost ring sights, while someone focused on home defense might opt for a tactical forend and a red dot sight.
For those seeking a compact and maneuverable shotgun, the Mossberg Shockwave vs Remington Tac-14 comparison is essential. Both offer short barrel lengths and pistol grips, making them ideal for close-quarters situations. The Mossberg Shockwave vs Remington Tac-14 debate often centers around legality, as some states have restrictions on short-barreled shotguns. Always check your local laws before purchasing.
The Mossberg Shockwave features a bird’s head grip, which provides a secure and comfortable hold. It’s known for its recoil-absorbing qualities and ease of handling. The Shockwave is a popular choice for home defense and recreational shooting.
The Remington 870 Tac-14 maintains a more traditional shotgun feel, with a pistol grip and a shortened forend. It offers a familiar shooting experience in a compact package. However, some users find the Tac-14’s recoil to be more pronounced than the Shockwave’s.
So, after all this, which shotgun comes out on top? The answer, as with most things, is “it depends.”
Regardless of which shotgun you choose, proper training and safe handling practices are paramount ( USA Shooting). Familiarize yourself with the shotgun’s operation, practice regularly, and always follow the four rules of gun safety. Remember to also consider responsible storage and adherence to all applicable laws and regulations. As a final note, always practice Leave No Trace principles when shooting outdoors ( Leave No Trace) – pack out all spent casings and targets.
Ultimately, the best way to decide between the Mossberg 500 vs Remington 870 is to handle both shotguns and see which one feels more comfortable and natural in your hands. Visit a local gun range or sporting goods store and try them out before making a purchase. A well-chosen shotgun can provide years of reliable service for hunting, home defense, and recreational shooting.